As wedding suppliers over the last 18 months, I’m sure the topic of a wedding deposit refund has come up more than once. We all know that Covid has come with a mountain of new and unique challenges for the wedding industry, the effects of which are still ongoing. As of yet, the courts have had limited cases concerning Covid for us to draw advice from.
There has, however, been a change in the water for videographers following the decision of the case ‘Spicer and another v Britton T/A Limelight Films (unreported), 16 April 2021‘. The court held that the videographer was not required to provide a wedding deposit refund after providing the client with alternative dates to re-schedule the wedding.
A few months on, we look at the practical impact of this for videographers and what it means for you now!

Summary of The Wedding Deposit Refund Case:
- Firstly, the CMA (Competition and Markets Authority) released official guidance that most contracts would be ‘frustrated’ by Covid, therefore requiring deposits to be refunded – I’m sure you’ve heard all about this!
- The Spicer case in question concerned a contract to film a wedding that was postponed due to Covid
- In trying to agree on a new date, the clients proposed one the videographer couldn’t make (sounding familiar!?)
- The videographer offered another date with an alternative videographer, however the clients refused this on the basis that it was an alternative
- The clients attempted to claim their wedding deposit refund (20%), relying on the guidance released by the CMA
- The videographer refused the refund, and the case went to court…
- In court, it was held that the contract was NOT, in fact, frustrated, and the deposit was not refunded!
This may seem unusual as it goes against CMA guidance, however the judge gave his own reasoning based upon 1) the express terms of the CONTRACT, 2) the significance of the date in the CONTRACT and 3) the clients having the option to reschedule.
If you want to read more about the case, check out this link explaining it in more detail:
So, what should you do when you find yourself in similar situations?
Firstly, deposits…
The judge ruled in favour of a non-frustrated contact, meaning the deposit did not have to be refunded. As a videographer you want the security of knowing you will not be forced to refund deposits. As mentioned, the express terms played a large part in the judge’s decision – which is why having a contract is SO important!
The express terms as written in the contracts provided here at Stanford Gould could protect you from refunding client deposits, similar to Spicer. The judge placed a large significance on the idea of reading all the terms in cohesion, therefore it’s important to have a comprehensive contract should this situation arise.

Bossy or stubborn clients…
The Spicer case gives us an insight into the world of pushy clients…we all know and have some!
In this case the clients were provided with an alternative date and videographer, but refused. It was the fact that the clients were given a choice that allowed the judge to find their contract to no longer be frustrated. A choice to ameliorate or resolve the issue of a contract cancelled or postponed by Covid can lead to no requirement for a wedding deposit refund.
Ability to reschedule…
Another example of the importance of having a contract! In Spicer, the judge looked at the significance of the date within the contract to see if rescheduling the wedding would allow the contract to continue.
As a videographer (or any contractor providing wedding services) it is important to know if you will be required to reschedule all the weddings postponed by Covid. It was held by the judge that even though the clients offered a reasonable alternate date, the videographer did not impact the contract by refusing that date because they offered another.
Lastly, being taken to court…
It may seem like a series of events that could never happen to you, especially over a wedding deposit refund, however you may find yourself being threatened with a county court claim by a client!
This is why it’s so important to have a written contract that can be depended upon should the case be taken to court. It may seem scary, but the written element of your agreement provides all the information about your obligations and protections.
All Stanford Gould contract templates are written to try and provide this protection in these situations – you’ll find them all HERE. If you aren’t confident in your contract, purchase one quickly and easily through the link provided!

