
Something a bit different for you today; a bit bruised and a bit battered, we have some real-life learning from one of our lovely wedding venue owners who has recently been through a small claims court experience. She has graciously offered to share her experience of the hearing, in the hope that whatever type of wedding supplier you are you may be able to take something away from this.

The background…
This small claims court experience belongs to a small family run venue, typical of the clients we speak to week in, week out. They have all the familiar problems; deposit disputes, CMA-style refund claims. In other words, they’re just like you…
The venue owner in question had the benefit of the guidance and caselaw from the Wedding Venue Support Group, some advice from us here at Stanford Gould, and the recent cases and legal decisions we’ve spoken about here on the blog.
Their customers were an engaged couple, who had booked and then cancelled during Covid times and demanded a full refund. For the purposes of simplicity, let’s assume the contract was frustrated and the dispute was about how much justifiable expenses could be retained by the venue, and how much should be returned to the couple. A classic CMA-style claim.
After resisting the claim and entering into negotiations to try and reach an out of court settlement, the venue’s efforts were not fruitful and the case progressed to a full small claims court hearing. In this small claims court experience the couple were awarded a refund, but not their full deposit. As the couple recovered more than had been offered, the venue was ordered to repay part of their deposit and the fees for bringing the court claim.
This is normal – the loser of the case pays the fees to bring the case, but no costs (such as lawyer’s costs or other professional fees)

What the venue owner told us about the small court claims experience, in their words…
- There are some fees to take into account
If you go to court and lose, even in the small claims court there is an issue fee and a hearing fee. For us this was around £500 in total, so wherever possible try and negotiate not going to court.
Note from SG: For our top tips on this issue, have a look at our dispute deals blog
- Everything must be evidenced
Creating good documents (written evidence and witness statements) as requested by the court for the hearing is essential. This should include a breakdown of costs and your business accounts, even if just in summary – these are critical. If you don’t include the evidence, everything including costs and estimations as part of your Defence (and/or counterclaim) will be struck out, as evidence has not been provided.
- Be very clear about your key dates and put them in the documents
- What date did the couple cancel
- What was the Government’s position on the date the couple cancelled (including evidence of this to prove whether the wedding was frustrated or the couple just cancelled)
For every change of date, it’s important to make it clear to couples that the original terms and conditions will apply and get them to SIGN something.
- Who attends the hearing?
Don’t just bring someone to the hearing with you unless you specifically state who they are and why they are there. We brought our Events Manager, but the judge didn’t like the fact that we hadn’t stated she was a witness or provided a witness statement for her.
- The Blame Game
The judge stated that neither party is at fault, neither party wishes to find themselves in a
contracted situation, and the claimant needs to realise that the venue is not required to refund all the amount paid as expenses. However, although we weren’t at fault, it was us that had to pay all the court fees and expenses.
- (un)reasonable behaviour
The litmus test is how reasonable the expenses occurred are. This is what we failed on, and the huge learning is not including copies of our accounts and a breakdown of our expenses in our submitted evidence – despite bringing them on the day, the judge would not look at anything that hadn’t been submitted in advance. The frustrating thing is that if we had included the breakdown of expenses and accounts, we would have had a different outcome.
7. Always take a calculator into court with you…
Note from SG: Work out if all this effort for a small claims court hearing is really worth it…!

The takeaways…
When speaking to the venue owner about her small claims court experience, she said this:
“I’m not a lawyer and have never been through the small claims process so didn’t know what to expect. This experience has been valuable. I was arrogant and over-confident that I was going to win, and being honest I failed to adequately prepare for the case in my submissions. I
submitted rushed evidence (due to the Claimant not sending me the information when they should have done and me going on holiday) and realised we need to be a lot more thorough in future submissions.
Lots of wedding venues are losing in the small claims, so try and negotiate before reaching court. On the positive side I kept my cool, showed empathy and didn’t get emotional which from my perspective was great. Above all, we defended our business and demonstrated integrity which is a massive personal value.
Thanks to all my staff and Heather at Stanford Gould for their support throughout the process.”
The venue may have lost the case, but there are a huge number of positives both professionally and personally with some steep learnings for the future, for all wedding suppliers in here.
